Skip to content

Plausibility lab

Legally and physiologically denotable hypotheses

Create a theory at any stage of the case. Point it at a statute, a rule, a constitutional clause, or a medical fact. Official text controls. This is not a finding and not a filing.

Create a new variable

A plausibility variable is a theory you can point at a statute, a rule, a constitutional clause, or a medical fact. Create one at any stage. It is not a finding.

On this case

None yet. Finish the survey or create one above.

Catalog you can add

legal

Warrantless vehicle search

The stop or the search of the car exceeded the Fourth Amendment and Iowa Const. art. I, § 8. Inventory, community-caretaking, or “plain view” may be a pretext.

legal

Warrantless home search

Entry into a home or curtilage without a warrant, valid consent, or a true exigency.

legal

Phone or digital search without a warrant

A cell phone is not a pair of shoes. Riley-style warrant rules often apply. Consent and extraction scope can be attacked.

legal

Consent to search was not voluntary

“Go ahead” given in custody, with weapons displayed, or after a claim that “we’ll just get a warrant” may not be free and voluntary.

legal

Custodial interrogation without Miranda

Statements after a functional arrest, before warnings and a valid waiver, may be suppressible. Silence still applies even if warnings were skipped.

mixed

Iowa Code § 804.20 was not honored

After arrival at the place of detention the person was not allowed, without unnecessary delay, to call, consult, and see a family member or an attorney — or both. Iowa’s statute is broader than Miranda and can suppress statements independently.

procedural

Charging paper does not identify the Iowa Code section or class

The magistrate must identify the charge. Until the written section and class are in hand, assume jail is possible and protect counsel and silence.

procedural

Speedy-trial clock

Rule 2.33: information often due shortly after arrest; trial generally within 90 days of information unless waived; a longer one-year clock from arraignment. Do not waive without counsel.

procedural

Statute of limitations / grandfathering

Chapter 802 limits when a prosecution may be commenced. The Code year in force on the incident date — not today’s reprint — is the starting point. Later ameliorative changes may still matter; later harsher changes usually do not.

legal

Constructive vs actual possession

Presence near a substance is not the same as dominion and control. Shared cars, shared rooms, and “whose stuff” questions belong to counsel — not to a jail phone.

legal

Subsequent-offense enhancement (e.g. 124.401(5))

A “3rd or subsequent” tag can change the class and the penalty. Prior convictions must actually qualify. Deferred judgments, out-of-state priors, and timing of priors are denotable — get the minutes.

mixed

Lab identity, weight, and chain of custody

Drug cases turn on what the lab says it is, how much, and who touched the bag. A field test is not a lab. Demand the minutes, the weight, and the chain.

physiological

Prescription or lawful possession vs illicit identity

The substance may be a prescribed medication, a lawful analog, or not the schedule the State named. Pharmacy records and a physician letter are evidence — not a speech to the detective.

physiological

Medical condition mimicking impairment

Diabetes, seizure, inner-ear, neurological, fatigue, or injury can look like intoxication to an officer. Field sobriety tests are not medical exams.

mixed

Field tests not accommodated for disability or language

Divided-attention tests assume English, two working legs, and no inner-ear disease. ADA Title II and due process both bite when the State treats a disability as “clues.”

mixed

Blood or breath draw without a valid warrant or implied-consent path

Bodily-intrusion draws are searches. Timing (rising BAC), mouth alcohol, GERD, and machine maintenance are physiological denotations; the warrant or statute is the legal one.

physiological

Competency to stand trial (ch. 812)

The question is whether the person can understand the proceedings and assist counsel — not whether they “did it.” Chapter 812 is a pause, not a defense on the merits.

legal

Justification / self-defense (ch. 704)

Force may be justified. This is fact-specific and easy to wreck by talking. Write a private timeline for counsel; do not post it.

procedural

No-contact order already in force

A no-contact order is its own case. Contact — even “just to explain” — can be a new crime. Third-party messages count.

procedural

New charge as a probation or parole violation

A plea or even an arrest can trigger a separate revocation. Do not talk to a probation officer about the new facts without counsel.

legal

Discovery / Brady material not produced

Body-cam, CAD, lab, prior-bad-act files, and deals with witnesses are often the case. Ask counsel to demand them in writing.

procedural

County attorney recusal / special prosecutor

A recusal is not a finding. Note who is now prosecuting, whether a conflict was stated, and whether deadlines moved. Still apply for counsel in the county of the case.

procedural

Release conditions vs cash bond

Chapter 811 looks at appearance risk and danger. “10% not allowed” means a bondsman may not post a fraction. Conditions (no-new-law, appear, testing) are court orders.

legal

Immigration consequences of a plea

A plea can be a conviction for immigration purposes even when the state calls it a deferred judgment. Tell counsel before any plea. This guide is not immigration advice.

procedural

Plea before counsel and the written charge

A plea is a conviction. It can cost a license, a job, a firearm right, housing, and — for non-citizens — the ability to stay. Hear the maximum and any enhancement on the record first.

procedural

10% cash not allowed

Some Iowa bond orders forbid posting 10% cash in lieu of the full amount. A bondsman posting a fraction may not satisfy that order. Read the exact words on the paper.

procedural

Initial appearance is not the trial

The first court date after a citation or arrest is usually an initial appearance or a status hearing. It is not the trial. A plea of guilty there is still a conviction.

procedural

Missed date / failure to appear

A missed criminal court date can add a warrant, a new charge, and revoked release. Call the clerk. A voicemail is not a continuance.

legal

Silence after invoking counsel

After a clear request for a lawyer, questioning about the facts should stop. Later “just one more question” is still interrogation. Write the timeline for counsel. Do not call the detective back to explain.